Skip to the content
The Library
of Alexandria
Sign inSign in1Try 3 months freeStart free
14 minSummaryRead it, the 15-minute summary, and print and large print at cost
What the Master Would Not Discuss, the audiobook coverAudiobook edition
StandardLarge printLarge print · 8.5 × 11 in · 560 pages · bigger, clearer type
What the Master Would Not Discuss, paperbackPaperback · 8.5 × 11 in · 470 pages
What the Master Would Not Discuss, hardcoverHardcover · 8.5 × 11 in · 470 pages
About this book

A traveller stops at an inn, a scholar reads late, and the unseen steps into ordinary life.

In What the Master Would Not Discuss, Yuan Mei gathers brief accounts of ghosts, fox spirits, strange omens and unsettling encounters. Scholars, clerks, merchants and families meet the supernatural in the familiar places of Qing dynasty life. A road at dusk or a quiet study becomes a place where human fears and desires take unexpected shapes.

The title draws on a saying in the Analects about subjects Confucius does not discuss. Yuan Mei turns toward those very subjects, presenting stories he hears from friends, relatives and travellers. Here, foxes take human form, and the dead have courts and records. Beneath the strangeness lie grief, loyalty, greed and the longing for justice.

What you’ll discover

  • Ghosts close to home Enter inns, studies and family houses where ordinary people encounter the unseen.
  • Foxes in human form Meet spirits who appear as scholars or beautiful women, bringing charm, tricks and sometimes love.
  • Paperwork beyond the grave Explore an underworld of magistrates, clerks and records that echoes the Chinese state.
  • Stories passed between people Follow accounts Yuan Mei presents through named tellers and places, giving strangeness a familiar setting.
  • Human hearts beneath horror Find wronged women, tempted scholars and families whose attachments reach into the supernatural.

Who will love it

Readers who enjoy ghost stories, fox spirits and courtroom mysteries will find plenty here, as will anyone curious about daily life in Qing China and fans of short tales with dry humor.

What’s inside

The key ideas, in the 15-minute summary

  1. Curiosity does not require belief
  2. Loyalty enters a dangerous ritual
  3. Ghosts need someone to hear them
  4. A clear head weakens fear
  5. The dead have officials too
  6. Foxes share human ambitions
  7. Fate speaks through misleading words
  8. The dead need their resting places
  9. Ordinary sense meets the uncanny

Who’s who

  • The old servantLoyal servant of Assistant Prefect Li who offers to die in his master's place and is saved by a barefoot monk's gift.
  • Judge BaoThe stern King of Hell who welcomes a living magistrate and agrees that false rites should stop.
  • Liu GangMagistrate of Fengdu who descends a well on a rope to end the yearly payments to the underworld.
  • CaiScholar who buys a haunted house near Hangzhou and calmly refuses a ghost's invitation to hang himself.
  • General Zhao LiangdongSoldier who insists on a haunted office and fights its leather-faced monster with his halberd.
  • The fox licentiateA fox who has passed the Lady of Mount Tai's examination and pursues a thousand-year road to immortality.

Read free up to chapter 2

Read the whole summary

Formats and delivery
eBook
On your phone, tablet, computer or Kindle, with the type as large as you like.
Large-print eBook
The same book in bigger, clearer type, from the first page.
15-minute summary
The key ideas in about 14 minutes, to read today.
Paperback
8.5 × 11 in, 470 pages: USD 22.95 when you start free, USD 28.95 on its own.
Hardcover
8.5 × 11 in, 470 pages: USD 31.95 when you start free, USD 37.95 on its own.
Large print paperback
8.5 × 11 in, 560 pages: USD 25.95 when you start free, USD 31.95 on its own.
Large print hardcover
8.5 × 11 in, 560 pages: USD 34.95 when you start free, USD 40.95 on its own.

Every printed copy is made when you order it and shipped worldwide; shipping is shown at checkout. The eBook opens when the book texts go online.

How it works
  1. Start free. Nothing to pay today; the eBook of this book is yours to keep.
  2. Read and print. 200,000+ classics as eBook, large-print eBook and 15-minute summary, and any book printed at cost as a paperback, hardcover or large print, 5 accounts for the price of one.
  3. We remind you first. Free for 3 months, and we email you 7 days before your first payment. Then USD 0.14 a day in your first year on the yearly plan and USD 0.27 a day after, or USD 0.66 a day on the monthly plan. Cancel online in two clicks.

Bought on its own? Every eBook and printed book you buy without the plan carries our 30-day money-back guarantee.

Start the yearly plan free · Start the monthly plan free

25 languages, side by side

What the Master Would Not Discuss in 25 languages, side by side, paragraph by paragraph, once the book texts are online: the way to learn a language with a book you love.

Short Stories

What the Master Would Not Discuss

by Yuan Mei · 1788

A servant offers his life to bring his dead master back, and a barefoot monk hands him five claws and a rope.

Challenging10–20 hours to read20 languages

Learn a language with challenging classicsSpanishFrenchGermanItalianJapanesePortugueseEnglishHow we measure levels

Format: eBook
Type size: Standard

Free for 3 months · starts right away, on any device

Read free3 months free · cancel anytime

Renews every year · Cancel anytimeHow it works

Or buy the eBook only · USD 6.95
We accept Visa, Mastercard, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Shop Pay.
  • Read, large type too
  • 25 languages, side by side
  • Print and large print at cost
  • 5 accounts for the price of one
Give this book as a gift
“Respect the spirits, but keep your distance.”
From the bookWhat the Master Would Not Discuss

In short

A servant loves his dead master so much that he offers his own life to bring him back. A Daoist priest agrees to perform the rite, a barefoot monk hands the servant a packet holding five claws and a rope, and the night of the ritual goes in a direction nobody expects.

What the Master Would Not Discuss by Yuan Mei, the cover

What the Master Would Not Discuss at a glance

Reading time
About 19 h 25 min15 h 20 min fast, 23 h 5 min slow
Length
276,700 words
Library level
Challenging long sentences, a rich vocabulary
First published
1788by Yuan Mei

Reading time at 238 words a minute (fast 300, slow 200). How long the classics take to read · Updated

From the 15-minute summary · Key idea 1

A scholar writes down what Confucius avoided

Yuan Mei opens with a puzzle. Confucius did not discuss the uncanny, force, disorder or spirits. Yet the old classics mention dragon's blood and ghost carts. Yuan answers that the ancient writers kept these marvels on record while teaching people to put life first.

Read every key idea free

Renews every year · Cancel anytime

Which edition is right for me
eBook
On your phone, tablet or computer. Your place follows you, and you can make the type as big as you like.
15-minute summary
The key ideas of the whole book in about 14 minutes. A good first look, or a refresher.
Paperback
Light and easy to carry. A real book for the bedside table and the beach.
Hardcover
Made to last. For the shelf, and for giving.
Large print paperback
Bigger, clearer type. Easy on the eyes for long evenings and for reading aloud.
Large print hardcover
Bigger, clearer type. Easy on the eyes for long evenings and for reading aloud.

See the type size

Pick a size and read a line at that size. Hold your phone at reading distance.

A servant offers his life to bring his dead master back, and a barefoot monk hands him five claws and a rope.

Shown close to the printed size on most screens.

8.5 × 11 inPaperback
8.5 × 11 inLarge print
A4for scale
Details
First published
1788
Language
English
Reading time
3 h 10 min
Level
Challenging
Paperback
470 pages · 8.5 × 11 in
Hardcover
470 pages · 8.5 × 11 in
Large print paperback
560 pages · 8.5 × 11 in
Large print hardcover
560 pages · 8.5 × 11 in
Delivery and returns
Arrives Sun 6 Dec to Sat 12 Decto United States, printed for you at cost

Cite this edition

Yuan, Mei. What the Master Would Not Discuss. Library of Alexandria, 2026, libraryofalexandria.com/products/what-the-master-would-not-discuss.

Free gifts

USD 580 in free gifts when you start

Every book in every format and in 25 languages, 5 accounts for the price of one. Nothing to pay today.

Try 3 months freeFree for 3 months · Renews every year · Cancel anytime
  • 200,000+ classic eBooksIn 25 languages, side by sideUSD 170FREE
  • Every eBookIn 25 languages, any deviceUSD 120FREE
  • 15-minute summariesRead in 25 languagesUSD 60FREE
  • Print at cost, no markupPaperback, hardcover, large printUSD 60FREE
  • 5 accounts for the price of oneA shelf for everyone at homeUSD 170FREE
  • A part in rebuilding the libraryNew languages and books for allFREE

Questions about What the Master Would Not Discuss

Can I read it free?

Yes. The first key idea of the 15-minute summary is free with no sign-up. Start free and the whole book is yours for 3 months, with the eBook to keep, plus 200,000+ more classics and any book printed at cost as a paperback, hardcover or large print. Nothing to pay today: we email you 7 days before your first payment, and you can cancel online in two clicks.

Can I buy just the printed book?

Yes. The paperback costs USD 28.95 on its own. Start free and you pay the cost of printing: USD 22.95 for this paperback, and any other book at cost as a paperback, hardcover or large print.

How many accounts do I get?

Five, for the price of one: you and 4 more people, each with their own login, shelf and their own place in every book.

Can I cancel anytime?

Yes. Cancel online in two clicks at any time and nothing more is charged. Nothing is charged in your first 3 months, and we email you 7 days before your first payment.

What is What the Master Would Not Discuss about?

It is a collection of hundreds of short Chinese tales about ghosts, fox spirits, dreams, haunted houses, underworld courts and strange lands. Yuan Mei gathered them from friends, officials and old books during the eighteenth century.

Why is it called What the Master Would Not Discuss?

The title refers to Confucius, who did not discuss the uncanny, force, disorder or spirits. Yuan first called it What Confucius Would Not Discuss, then changed it to New Records of the Uncanny after finding a similar older title.

Are the stories true or made up?

Yuan says he writes the tales down not because he believes them but for entertainment. Many name a person who told the story or give a date and place, which gives them the feel of reports.

The author

Yuan Mei

1716–1797 · Chinese Qing dynasty poet

Yuan Mei (1716–1797) was a Chinese poet, essayist, and scholar of the Qing dynasty. He was born in Hangzhou and later lived in Nanjing. He served as a government official before retiring. During the eighteenth century, he wrote poetry, essays, Suiyuan Poetry Talks, and What the Master Would Not Discuss.

“Respect the spirits, but keep your distance.”
What the Master Would Not Discuss, preface, quoting Confucius

More by Yuan Mei

See all their books

More like this

Our mission

The library burned once. We are building it back.

Every great book, in every language and every format, for every family. Every plan helps pay for new languages and books for readers who have never had them. Join the movement.

Read our story
  • Every language25 languages today, side by side, and more every year
  • No wastePrinted on demand: no warehouses, no unsold stock, no pulped copies
  • For everyonePaperback, hardcover and large print at the cost of printing

Popular in short stories

See all
What the Master Would Not DiscussFree for 3 months · nothing to pay today
Read free