Skip to the content
The Library
of Alexandria
Sign inSign inTry 3 months freeStart free
14 minSummaryRead it, the 15-minute summary, and print and large print at cost
The Light That Lies, the audiobook coverAudiobook edition
StandardBut the law is never sorry.Large printBut the law is never sorry.Large print · 6 × 9 in · 134 pages · bigger, clearer type
The Light That Lies, paperbackPaperback · 6 × 9 in · 84 pages
The Light That Lies, hardcoverHardcover · 6 × 9 in · 84 pages
About this book

What happens when public duty asks for one choice, and the heart insists on another?

In The Light That Lies, George Barr McCutcheon brings romance into the courtroom. Duty and desire pull in different directions, and a verdict promises to alter lives. Love is not the only claim that matters here. Honour and obligation stand beside it, making private longing a question with public consequences.

This early twentieth century American romance offers direct storytelling, open feelings and clear emotional stakes. The courtroom gives the conflict a public stage, where what people want meets what they owe. Read for the pull between love and honour, and for a story that asks how either can guide a difficult choice.

What you’ll discover

  • Duty against desire Explore the strain of wanting something that a public role may not allow.
  • Love beside obligation Consider what love asks when honour places its own demands on the heart.
  • A courtroom stage Enter a setting where private feelings meet the pressure of a public decision.
  • A life-altering verdict Read toward a judgment whose consequences reach beyond the courtroom and into personal lives.
  • Feelings in plain sight Enjoy a romance whose direct style gives love and moral choices room to matter.

Who will love it

You will enjoy this book if you like courtroom scenes, gentle comedy, and love stories told with a wink. It suits anyone who wants a lively tale about duty, honor, and the way one glance can change a mind.

What’s inside

The key ideas, in the 15-minute summary

  1. Curiosity catches a practiced jury dodger
  2. Alexandra changes his reason for staying
  3. Questions expose a witness's hidden motives
  4. Every juror feels personally trusted
  5. A denial leaves the evidence unresolved
  6. Sampson questions the sympathy they share
  7. Sincere appearances can still mislead
  8. Humor carries the serious question
  9. Honesty can cost what you want

Who’s who

  • SampsonA rich, young New York steamship owner who has dodged jury duty for years and now wants to do right by the law and by a woman.
  • Alexandra HildebrandThe calm, perceptive granddaughter of the accused, who trusts that the truth will free him and watches the jurors closely.
  • James W. HildebrandA gray, dignified seventy-year-old charged with taking fifty thousand dollars, who denies it and will not say why he fled.
  • Mr. StevensThe prim head of the Cornwallis Realty and Investment Company and the State's main witness, with an old grudge against the family.
  • Mr. O'BrienThe smooth defense lawyer who takes apart the State's witnesses with quiet, pointed questions.
  • TurpleSampson's loyal English valet, who loves blue serge and is amazed by his master's sudden cheer.
  • Mr. HooperJuror number eight, a hat salesman who puffs out his chest and presses Sampson to give in.
  • Juror Number SevenA lovesick electrical supplier who takes off his hat to Alexandra and cannot stop thinking about her.

Read free up to chapter 2

Read the whole summary

Formats and delivery
eBook
On your phone, tablet, computer or Kindle, with the type as large as you like.
Large-print eBook
The same book in bigger, clearer type, from the first page.
15-minute summary
The key ideas in about 14 minutes, to read today.
Paperback
6 × 9 in, 84 pages: USD 5.95 when you start free, USD 12.95 on its own.
Hardcover
6 × 9 in, 84 pages: USD 14.95 when you start free, USD 20.95 on its own.
Large print paperback
6 × 9 in, 134 pages: USD 6.95 when you start free, USD 13.95 on its own.
Large print hardcover
6 × 9 in, 134 pages: USD 15.95 when you start free, USD 22.95 on its own.

Every printed copy is made when you order it and shipped worldwide; shipping is shown at checkout. The eBook opens when the book texts go online.

How it works
  1. Start free. Nothing to pay today; the eBook of this book is yours to keep.
  2. Read and print. 200,000+ classics as eBook, large-print eBook and 15-minute summary, and any book printed at cost as a paperback, hardcover or large print, 5 accounts for the price of one.
  3. We remind you first. Free for 3 months, and we email you 7 days before your first payment. Then USD 0.14 a day in your first year on the yearly plan and USD 0.27 a day after, or USD 0.66 a day on the monthly plan. Cancel online in two clicks.

Bought on its own? Every eBook and printed book you buy without the plan carries our 30-day money-back guarantee.

Start the yearly plan free · Start the monthly plan free

25 languages, side by side

The Light That Lies in 25 languages, side by side, paragraph by paragraph, once the book texts are online: the way to learn a language with a book you love.

Romance

The Light That Lies

by George Barr McCutcheon

A man who dodges jury duty lands on an embezzlement trial and cannot stop watching the accused's granddaughter.

Medium levelUnder 2 hours to read20 languages

Learn a language with medium classicsSpanishFrenchGermanItalianJapanesePortugueseEnglishHow we measure levels

Format: eBook
Type size: Standard

Free for 3 months · starts right away, on any device

Read free3 months free · cancel anytime

Renews every year · Cancel anytimeHow it works

Or buy the eBook only · USD 6.95
We accept Visa, Mastercard, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Shop Pay.
  • Read, large type too
  • 25 languages, side by side
  • Print and large print at cost
  • 5 accounts for the price of one
Give this book as a gift
“But the law is never sorry.”
From the bookThe Light That Lies

In short

What happens when a man who has spent years dodging jury duty is finally caught? In The Light That Lies, Sampson is a rich young New Yorker, a Harvard graduate, and the owner of a steamship company.

The Light That Lies by George Barr McCutcheon, the cover

The Light That Lies at a glance

Reading time
About 1 h 40 min1 h 20 min fast, 2 h slow
Length
24,200 words
Library level
Medium longer sentences, everyday words

Reading time at 238 words a minute (fast 300, slow 200). How long the classics take to read · Updated

From the 15-minute summary · Key idea 1

A professional dodger of jury duty is caught

Sampson is thirty, rich, single, a Harvard man, and president of the Sampson Steamship and Navigation Company, a post he inherited from his father. His real career is escaping jury duty. He has told one court that he doubts circumstantial evidence, another that he does not accept insanity as a defense, and another that he has changed his mind about capital punishment. Each excuse works once.

Read every key idea free

Renews every year · Cancel anytime

Which edition is right for me
eBook
On your phone, tablet or computer. Your place follows you, and you can make the type as big as you like.
15-minute summary
The key ideas of the whole book in about 14 minutes. A good first look, or a refresher.
Paperback
Light and easy to carry. A real book for the bedside table and the beach.
Hardcover
Made to last. For the shelf, and for giving.
Large print paperback
Bigger, clearer type. Easy on the eyes for long evenings and for reading aloud.
Large print hardcover
Bigger, clearer type. Easy on the eyes for long evenings and for reading aloud.

See the type size

Pick a size and read a line at that size. Hold your phone at reading distance.

A man who dodges jury duty lands on an embezzlement trial and cannot stop watching the accused's granddaughter.

Shown close to the printed size on most screens.

6 × 9 inPaperback
6 × 9 inLarge print
A4for scale
Details
Language
English
Reading time
1 h 55 min
Level
Medium level
Paperback
84 pages · 6 × 9 in
Hardcover
84 pages · 6 × 9 in
Large print paperback
134 pages · 6 × 9 in
Large print hardcover
134 pages · 6 × 9 in
Delivery and returns
Arrives Mon 7 Dec to Sun 13 Decto United States, printed for you at cost

Cite this edition

McCutcheon, George Barr. The Light That Lies. Library of Alexandria, 2026, libraryofalexandria.com/products/the-light-that-lies.

Free gifts

USD 580 in free gifts when you start

Every book in every format and in 25 languages, 5 accounts for the price of one. Nothing to pay today.

Try 3 months freeFree for 3 months · Renews every year · Cancel anytime
  • 200,000+ classic eBooksIn 25 languages, side by sideUSD 170FREE
  • Every eBookIn 25 languages, any deviceUSD 120FREE
  • 15-minute summariesRead in 25 languagesUSD 60FREE
  • Print at cost, no markupPaperback, hardcover, large printUSD 60FREE
  • 5 accounts for the price of oneA shelf for everyone at homeUSD 170FREE
  • A part in rebuilding the libraryNew languages and books for allFREE

Questions about The Light That Lies

Can I read it free?

Yes. The first key idea of the 15-minute summary is free with no sign-up. Start free and the whole book is yours for 3 months, with the eBook to keep, plus 200,000+ more classics and any book printed at cost as a paperback, hardcover or large print. Nothing to pay today: we email you 7 days before your first payment, and you can cancel online in two clicks.

Can I buy just the printed book?

Yes. The paperback costs USD 12.95 on its own. Start free and you pay the cost of printing: USD 5.95 for this paperback, and any other book at cost as a paperback, hardcover or large print.

How many accounts do I get?

Five, for the price of one: you and 4 more people, each with their own login, shelf and their own place in every book.

Can I cancel anytime?

Yes. Cancel online in two clicks at any time and nothing more is charged. Nothing is charged in your first 3 months, and we email you 7 days before your first payment.

What is The Light That Lies about?

It tells of Sampson, a wealthy New Yorker who has always avoided jury duty and finally lands on an embezzlement trial. He falls for the accused man's granddaughter and must weigh his duty against his feelings.

Who is Alexandra Hildebrand in The Light That Lies?

She is the calm, clever granddaughter of James W. Hildebrand, the accused. She sits beside him in court, helps choose the jurors, and trusts that the truth will clear him. Sampson falls in love with her.

What does the title The Light That Lies mean?

The book never explains it in plain words. Readers often take it to mean the bright, trusting look of a lovely face, which can mislead a man's judgment and make him doubt the evidence in front of him.

The author

George Barr McCutcheon

1866–1928 · American novelist

George Barr McCutcheon was an American novelist born in Tippecanoe County, Indiana, in 1866. He worked as a newspaper reporter in Lafayette, Indiana. His novels include Graustark, published in 1901, and Brewster’s Millions, published in 1902 under the name Richard Greaves. He died in New York City in 1928.

“But the law is never sorry.”
The Light That Lies, chapter 1, the assistant district attorney

More by George Barr McCutcheon

See all their books

More like this

Our mission

The library burned once. We are building it back.

Every great book, in every language and every format, for every family. Every plan helps pay for new languages and books for readers who have never had them. Join the movement.

Read our story
  • Every language25 languages today, side by side, and more every year
  • No wastePrinted on demand: no warehouses, no unsold stock, no pulped copies
  • For everyonePaperback, hardcover and large print at the cost of printing

Popular in romance

See all
The Light That LiesFree for 3 months · nothing to pay today
Read free