Summary
Summary of The Science of Fairy Tales
Key ideas
Key idea 1
Fairy tales are shared traditions
A midwife enters a hidden hall, where she must refuse every bite of food. A changeling hears beer brewing in an eggshell and cries out. Edwin Sidney Hartland approaches these strange moments by setting tales beside one another. Stories from Wales, Germany and Scandinavia meet stories from the South Seas, Asia and Africa.
His starting point is that fairy tales are traditions, not literature. Comparing them offers a way to understand why their curious rules and events belong in the stories.
Key idea 2
Old beliefs make strange events sensible
A bear can be a man in disguise because changing shape need not mean changing identity.
Start free to read
Key idea 3
Sharing fairy food creates a bond
The human midwife summoned to a fairy birth receives a warning: take no food or drink.
Start free to read
Key idea 4
Fairy generosity depends on keeping terms
A fairy payment may look worthless until the helper gets home.
Start free to read
Key idea 5
Forbidden sight brings fairy punishment
A midwife puts fairy ointment on her own eye and gains sight she was never meant to possess.
Start free to read
Key idea 6
Changeling beliefs put children at risk
Fear for a helpless newborn led families to guard the cradle with light, iron, scissors or the father's clothes.
Start free to read
Key idea 7
Fairy encounters unsettle possessions and time
Men who seize a fairy cup or horn may escape pursuit by reaching running water or a crossroads, yet still pay a price later.
Start free to read
Key idea 8
Fairy marriages depend on a taboo
A man takes a bathing maiden's feather robe and gains a wife, but she can fly home when she recovers it.
Start free to read
Key idea 9
Comparison reveals beliefs beneath the tales
Hartland brings the tales together through the beliefs they preserve.
Start free to read
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
Read the rest free
Go deeper: the whole of The Science of Fairy Tales
About 8 h 40 min to read.Who it’s for
For lovers of folklore, fairy lore and Celtic or Germanic legend, and for anyone who enjoys asking where an old story came from and what its odd details once meant.
What this book is
Why must a midwife taken to a hidden hall refuse every bite of food? Why does a changeling cry out when beer brews in an eggshell? Edwin Sidney Hartland answers with comparison. He sets fairy tales of Wales, Germany and Scandinavia beside stories from the South Seas, Asia and Africa. You get a method for reading old tales, and the first idea is simple: these tales are traditions, not literature.
In this summary
- 1Fairy tales are traditions, not literatureFree
- 2Early ideas about spirits explain strange plots
- 3Never eat the food of the other world
- 4Fairy gifts come with conditions
- 5Fairies punish anyone who pries
- 6Changelings come from fear for the helpless child
- 7Stolen cups and lost time in Fairyland
- 8Sleeping heroes and enchanted princesses are old gods
- 9Swan maidens and the taboo
Key point 1 of 9
Fairy tales are traditions, not literature
Hartland studies tales kept alive by generations of tellers. He asks what they preserve of beliefs and customs from the distant past. Works shaped by authors like Hans Andersen belong to literary criticism instead, unless they offer evidence of an older tradition.
He shows how carefully people keep stories. In the Scottish Highlands, travelling tailors and shoemakers carried tales from house to house on winter nights. A Sicilian woman named Agatuzza Messia told tales her grandmother had told her, with her eyes, arms and voice. In Greenland, listeners corrected any slip in the old words.
So a collector must record an uneducated teller's words exactly, keeping every rough edge. Smoothing a coarse or silly detail may destroy the very clue a student needs. The odd parts of a tale are the valuable parts.
That’s 1 of 9 key points.
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
- Nothing to pay today · Renews every year
- We email you before you pay
- Cancel online in two clicks
Check yourself
Why does Hartland compare fairy tales from different places?
Right. “When a tale seems absurd, ask which old belief makes it sensible.”Not quite. “When a tale seems absurd, ask which old belief makes it sensible.”
Why must human visitors refuse fairy food?
Right. “To eat with spirits, whether dead or fairy, is to join them and leave human company.”Not quite. “To eat with spirits, whether dead or fairy, is to join them and leave human company.”
What does Hartland acknowledge about supposed changelings?
Right. “Hartland admits that the so-called changelings were sick or deformed children.”Not quite. “Hartland admits that the so-called changelings were sick or deformed children.”
Go deeper: the whole of The Science of Fairy Tales
About 8 h 40 min to read.Questions about The Science of Fairy Tales
What is The Science of Fairy Tales about?
Hartland compares them with stories from around the world to show what early beliefs lie behind them.
What does Hartland mean by the science of fairy tales?
He means the study of traditional stories passed on by mouth, treated as evidence of old customs and beliefs. It differs from literary criticism, which looks at an author's art. Collected tales must be recorded exactly.
What is a changeling in this book?
A changeling is a fairy child or enchanted block of wood left in place of a stolen human baby. Hartland describes the protective charms, the eggshell test that makes the child give itself away, and the cures people tried.
Is it a true account of fairies or of folk belief?
It reports folk belief and legend, often with sources and places named. Hartland, writing in 1890, argues the stories reflect early thought about spirits, transformation and magic rather than real events.
Is The Science of Fairy Tales easy to follow?
Many chapters follow a group of tales, with vivid stories to carry the argument, such as the midwife with the apron of coals or the dancer in the fairy ring. Chapter headings preview each topic.
Cite this edition
Hartland, Edwin Sidney. The Science of Fairy Tales. Library of Alexandria, 2026, libraryofalexandria.com/products/the-science-of-fairy-tales.
Hartland, E. S. (2026). The science of fairy tales. Library of Alexandria. https://libraryofalexandria.com/products/the-science-of-fairy-tales (Original work published 1891)
Hartland, Edwin Sidney. The Science of Fairy Tales. Library of Alexandria, 2026. https://libraryofalexandria.com/products/the-science-of-fairy-tales.
@book{hartland2026science,
author = {Hartland, Edwin Sidney},
title = {The Science of Fairy Tales},
publisher = {Library of Alexandria},
year = {2026},
url = {https://libraryofalexandria.com/products/the-science-of-fairy-tales},
note = {First published 1891}
}
