Summary
Summary of The Ball and the Cross
Key ideas
Key idea 1
Belief becomes a comic adventure
Two men believe what they say, and neither is willing to hide that belief behind politeness. Chesterton turns their disagreement into a comic adventure: a Catholic from the Scottish Highlands faces an atheist from the Lowlands, while a chase across England keeps interrupting their proposed duel.
The question beneath the jokes is whether these enemies take ideas more seriously than the world around them. Their willingness to risk something for conviction gives the adventure its serious purpose.
Key idea 2
Two worldviews meet above London
Start free to read
Key idea 3
An insult brings enemies together
Start free to read
Key idea 4
Polite tolerance dismisses their convictions
Start free to read
Key idea 5
Their quarrel becomes a friendship
Start free to read
Key idea 6
Courage tests belief and doubt
Start free to read
Key idea 7
Paradox gives the ideas shape
Start free to read
Key idea 8
Argument can express real respect
Start free to read
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
Read the rest freeWho it’s for
For readers who enjoy a debate with a plot, comic adventures and friendships born of fierce disagreement, and anyone curious about Chesterton's wit and his faith.
What this book is
The Ball and the Cross is a novel by G. K. Chesterton, first printed in a magazine and then as a book in the years before the First World War. It is a comic adventure with a serious question inside it. What happens when two men truly believe what they say, and will not agree to be polite about it? Chesterton was a journalist, a poet and a lively debater in print, and he wrote this tale as a fantasy with a flying ship, a chase across England and a duel that no one will allow.
You get a fast story, a lot of jokes and a long argument carried on by people who would rather fight than shrug. The book sets a Catholic from the Scottish Highlands against an atheist from the Lowlands, and it asks which of them takes ideas more seriously than the modern world does. To see how the book begins, start high above London, where a strange machine hangs over the dome of St Paul's.
In this summary
- 1A flying ship above St Paul'sFree
- 2Two men and an insulted faith
- 3The law will not let them fight
- 4A chase through a polite England
- 5What the quarrel is really about
- 6How Chesterton tells the tale
Key point 1 of 6
A flying ship above St Paul's
The story opens in the air over London. A flying machine hangs above the dome of St Paul's Cathedral, and in it sit two very different passengers. One is a scientist known as Professor Lucifer. The other is Michael, a monk from the East who has lived a quiet life of prayer. The professor is shown to be more than a mere inventor, and the reader soon senses that he is the old tempter in modern clothes.
The ship drifts close to the top of the cathedral, where a great ball is crowned by a cross. The title comes from this sight. For Chesterton the ball and the cross are two shapes that stand for two ways of seeing the world, a closed circle and a sign that cuts through it.
Lucifer argues like a man who thinks he is doing humanity a favour. He wants to free people from what he calls the old superstitions. He speaks of progress, of science and of a world that has outgrown its myths. The monk answers him calmly and with a plain stubbornness that annoys the professor.
This opening scene sets up the whole book. It tells you that the quarrel is not only about ideas but about a person who wants the ideas to win. It also shows Chesterton's method. A grand argument is dressed as an adventure, and the characters speak in bright, surprising images rather than in dry lectures.
That’s 1 of 6 key points.
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
- Nothing to pay today · Renews every year
- We email you before you pay
- Cancel online in two clicks
Check yourself
Why is Turnbull delighted by MacIan's response to his paper?
Right. “At last he has met a man who cares about God enough to break glass over him.”Not quite. “At last he has met a man who cares about God enough to break glass over him.”
What do the two men find objectionable about the magistrate's tolerance?
Right. “It simply declines to treat them as important.”Not quite. “It simply declines to treat them as important.”
How does the relationship between MacIan and Turnbull change during their travels?
Right. “But they have more in common with each other than with the cheerful crowds who keep calling them fools, and a strange friendship grows in the middle of the quarrel.”Not quite. “But they have more in common with each other than with the cheerful crowds who keep calling them fools, and a strange friendship grows in the middle of the quarrel.”
Questions about The Ball and the Cross
What is The Ball and the Cross about?
It follows a Scottish Catholic and a Scottish atheist who want to fight a duel over religion while England keeps stopping them. Above them, a scientist who stands for doubt argues with a monk.
What does the title The Ball and the Cross mean?
It refers to the ball and cross on top of St Paul's Cathedral in London. Chesterton uses them as symbols of two ways of seeing the world, a closed circle and a sign of faith.
Who are MacIan and Turnbull in The Ball and the Cross?
Evan MacIan is a devout Highland Catholic, and James Turnbull is a Lowland atheist who edits a paper. Their quarrel over an insult to the Virgin Mary drives the plot.
Is The Ball and the Cross a hard book to read?
It is not hard in language. Readers who enjoy ideas and wit will find it lively.
What is the main message of The Ball and the Cross?
Chesterton argues that sincere belief, even when it causes conflict, is more alive than easy tolerance that treats nothing as important. He also gives the atheist hero respect and honest strength.
