Summary
Summary of That Affair Next Door
Key ideas
Key idea 1
An overlooked woman becomes an investigator
Miss Amelia Butterworth has money, firm opinions and a sharp eye for other people’s business. When a shocking event takes place next door, this unmarried New York woman refuses to remain a bystander. She tells the story herself, revealing both her intelligence and her pride.
Her encounter with the veteran detective Ebenezer Gryce brings together two different kinds of investigator. Their uneasy partnership makes room for a woman whom others might overlook to test her judgment against professional police work.
Key idea 2
Knowing the street makes differences visible
Start free to read
Key idea 3
A nearby death threatens a household
Start free to read
Key idea 4
Two investigators compete for the truth
Start free to read
Key idea 5
Domestic knowledge becomes real evidence
Start free to read
Key idea 6
Respectability can hide private fears
Start free to read
Key idea 7
Amelia’s voice shapes every clue
Start free to read
Key idea 8
Observation and pride work against secrecy
Start free to read
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
Read the rest freeWho it’s for
For readers who love classic puzzle mysteries, Victorian settings, and a narrator with a strong personality, and anyone curious about the roots of the detective story.
What this book is
That Affair Next Door is a detective novel by Anna Katharine Green, published in 1897. Green was among the first writers in English to build whole novels around police work and clues, and by this date she had a loyal readership. Here she gives the reader a new kind of investigator. Miss Amelia Butterworth is a well-off, unmarried New York woman of a certain age, with sharp eyes, firm opinions and a great deal of free time.
The story is told by Amelia herself, in her own proud and often funny voice. A shocking event in the house next door draws her in, and she cannot stand aside. She meets Ebenezer Gryce, the veteran police detective who appears in several of Green's books, and the two become wary partners and rivals. Along the way you get a mystery of deception in respectable society, a detailed picture of Victorian city life, and the pleasure of watching a woman others overlook outthink the professionals. First, let us look at the woman at the window.
In this summary
- 1A watchful neighbor at her windowFree
- 2Something is wrong in the house next door
- 3An old detective meets a determined amateur
- 4What a woman's eye can see
- 5Respectability, class and hidden lives
- 6A voice that carries the mystery
Key point 1 of 6
A watchful neighbor at her window
The story begins with Amelia Butterworth, who tells it in the first person. She lives in a quiet, comfortable part of New York, and she knows her street well. She is unmarried, independent and sure of her own judgment. She also has a habit that she does not quite admit to, which is watching what goes on around her.
From her window she sees the comings and goings of her neighbors. Those who live nearby are people of standing, and Amelia knows who they are and how they ought to behave. That knowledge matters. A person who knows what is normal in a street will spot what is not. Green makes this the foundation of the whole book, because it explains why Amelia notices what the police do not.
The tone is set early. Amelia is vain about her good sense and a little snobbish about her position, and she tells us so without meaning to. The reader smiles at her, yet also starts to trust her. She is a woman of habit and manners, and her habits are exactly what will make her useful.
This opening also teaches you how to read the novel. Every small detail from her window may matter later, from who arrives, to who is expected, to what looks out of place. Green asks you to look as closely as Amelia does, and to weigh each observation against the others.
That’s 1 of 6 key points.
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
- Nothing to pay today · Renews every year
- We email you before you pay
- Cancel online in two clicks
Check yourself
Why does Amelia’s knowledge of her street help her investigate?
Right. “A person who knows what is normal in a street will spot what is not.”Not quite. “A person who knows what is normal in a street will spot what is not.”
What makes Amelia and Gryce rivals as well as partners?
Right. “Both want the truth, and both want to be the one who finds it.”Not quite. “Both want the truth, and both want to be the one who finds it.”
What does the investigation reveal about respectable appearances?
Right. “A fine house, a good family and a polished manner can hide fear, lies and desperate choices.”Not quite. “A fine house, a good family and a polished manner can hide fear, lies and desperate choices.”
Questions about That Affair Next Door
What is That Affair Next Door about?
It is a detective novel in which Amelia Butterworth, a curious New York spinster, becomes involved in a crime in the house next to hers and works with and against the police detective Ebenezer Gryce.
Who is Amelia Butterworth?
She is the narrator and amateur detective, a well-off, independent woman with a sharp eye for her neighbors. She appears in other Anna Katharine Green novels, and readers enjoy her pride and humor.
Who is Ebenezer Gryce?
Gryce is a New York police detective who appears in several Green novels, starting with The Leavenworth Case. He is patient, observant and shrewd, and he treats Amelia with courtesy and caution.
When was That Affair Next Door written?
It was published in 1897. It is a work of fiction, set in contemporary Victorian-era New York, and it belongs to the early period of the detective novel.
Is That Affair Next Door hard to read?
Amelia's lively voice and the clear puzzle structure make it easy to follow.
