Summary
Summary of An American Suffragette
Key ideas
Key idea 1
A homecoming unsettles an approved engagement
Dr. John Earl returns to New York wanting only to practice medicine, but his private life soon raises questions his travels have not answered. He is engaged to Leonora Kimball, a match welcomed by their wealthy families. Yet he has scarcely considered whether they share a view of life.
A suffrage parade draws him into the street, where he recognizes a woman he has noticed abroad. She is Silvia Holland, a lawyer who earns her own living. His interest in her begins to unsettle the future society has already approved for him.
Key idea 2
An injured child brings them together
Start free to read
Key idea 3
Shared beliefs expose divided loyalties
Start free to read
Key idea 4
Political meetings put assumptions on trial
Start free to read
Key idea 5
Suspicion turns a doctor into an accused
Start free to read
Key idea 6
Independence links the novel's central struggles
Start free to read
Key idea 7
Public judgment tests private bonds
Start free to read
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
Read the rest freeWho it’s for
For readers who like courtroom suspense, early twentieth century New York society, and stories where love and a public cause pull on the same people. Fans of suffrage history will find plenty to enjoy.
What this book is
An American Suffragette is a novel by Isaac Newton Stevens, who died in 1920. It was written in the years when the vote for women was among the loudest questions in New York, London and the American West. It joins a love story, a courtroom drama and a running argument about who should hold power in a democracy.
The hero is Dr. John Earl, a young New York surgeon who comes home from India with new ideas about healing the mind and the body together. The heroine is Silvia Holland, a rich young lawyer who marches for the vote and insists on earning her own living. Around them stand a fiancée from the anti-suffrage set, a brilliant rival surgeon, a cheerful brother from Colorado and a sharp woman reporter. You get a fast story, plenty of talk, and a trial that grips the whole city. Let us begin with the doctor's return to a New York that has changed while he was away.
In this summary
- 1A Doctor Returns to a Changed CityFree
- 2A Fortune Teller and a Child in Need
- 3Two Women and a Jealous Rival
- 4Meetings That Test Every Opinion
- 5Poison in a Box of Fruit
- 6What the Novel Argues and How It Speaks
Key point 1 of 6
A Doctor Returns to a Changed City
The story opens on a New York pier, where reporters crowd around Dr. John Earl as his ship from England docks. Word has spread that he saved a copper king named Hall in Paris. The French surgeons feared Hall's heart was too weak for an anesthetic, so Earl placed him in a deep trance, and the operation went ahead. Earl refuses every interview. He says he has come home only to practice his profession.
Waiting for him are his brother Frank, a railroad lawyer who lives in Colorado, and his sister Hilda, who is married to the banker George Ramsey. With them is Leonora Kimball, the pretty daughter of a wealthy family, who became engaged to John in Vienna. Their fortunes match, and New York society approves. The author adds a quiet warning. Earl has searched the world for the causes of disease, yet he chooses a wife the way millions of men do, by habit and without asking whether they share a view of life.
That same April afternoon, a drum and fife draw him to his hotel window. Six thousand women march down Fifth Avenue in a suffrage parade, and he follows it for many blocks. At the head of the column, a tall young woman in white and black carries a banner. He has seen her twice before, once in a London protest outside Parliament and once at the Paris opera. He calls her his Mystery.
At dinner that night, Hilda names her. She is Silvia Holland, daughter of a steel magnate, a graduate of Columbia's law school, and a woman who pays her own rent. Frank teases his brother without mercy, and admits he followed the parade himself. The Ramseys decide the whole party will go to the suffrage ball that evening.
That’s 1 of 6 key points.
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
- Nothing to pay today · Renews every year
- We email you before you pay
- Cancel online in two clicks
Check yourself
What does Silvia insist women need alongside political rights?
Right. “She insists that women need economic independence, and she lends money to Mrs. Bell in the hope of teaching her self-reliance.”Not quite. “She insists that women need economic independence, and she lends money to Mrs. Bell in the hope of teaching her self-reliance.”
What turns Earl's life into a courtroom struggle?
Right. “Within days, the press, rival surgeons and anonymous letters all point at Earl, and the public takes his guilt for granted.”Not quite. “Within days, the press, rival surgeons and anonymous letters all point at Earl, and the public takes his guilt for granted.”
How does Earl's medical struggle resemble the suffragists' political struggle?
Right. “Both groups are called faddists, and both face men who defend the way things are done.”Not quite. “Both groups are called faddists, and both face men who defend the way things are done.”
Questions about An American Suffragette
What is An American Suffragette about?
It tells of Dr. John Earl, a New York surgeon home from India, and Silvia Holland, a young lawyer and suffragist. Their meeting, a child's accident and a mysterious death lead to a sensational murder trial.
Who is Silvia Holland in the novel?
Silvia is a wealthy young attorney, a graduate of Columbia's law school, who marches in the suffrage parade. She pays her own way, helps working women and takes on the defense of a man in grave danger.
Is An American Suffragette based on a true story?
It is a novel, not a record of real events. It does draw on the real suffrage campaigns of its time, including the English militants, the New York parades and the voting women of Colorado.
Is An American Suffragette easy to read?
The story moves along with clear scenes, lively conversation and a steady mystery. Frank Earl's jokes and short chapters give the book a brisk, friendly pace, and the legal scenes are easy to follow.
What is the main message of the book?
The author argues that democracy is stronger when women share fully in public life and earn their own independence. He also champions open-minded medicine and urges fair judgment before condemning anyone.
