A Dream Within a Dream

by Edgar Allan Poe · 1849 · Čitanje: 1 min · 24 redaka

Ukratko

“A Dream Within a Dream” by Edgar Allan Poe is a poem about loss and the uncertainty of what is real. It begins with a farewell kiss on the brow as the speaker admits that life has seemed like a dream. The speaker then considers lost hope, suggesting that how it disappeared does not make its loss less real. The scene shifts to a roaring shore, where the speaker holds a few grains of golden sand. As the sand slips through the fingers toward the water, the speaker weeps and calls on God for help saving even one grain. The poem ends by turning its earlier claim about life into a question, leaving the speaker’s uncertainty unresolved.

Take this kiss upon the brow!And, in parting from you now,Thus much let me avow—You are not wrong, who deemThat my days have been a dream;Yet if hope has flown awayIn a night, or in a day,In a vision, or in none,Is it therefore the less gone?All that we see or seemIs but a dream within a dream.

I stand amid the roarOf a surf-tormented shore,And I hold within my handGrains of the golden sand—How few! yet how they creepThrough my fingers to the deep,While I weep—while I weep!O God! can I not graspThem with a tighter clasp?O God! can I not saveOne from the pitiless wave?Is all that we see or seemBut a dream within a dream?

Što to znači, redak po redak

Retci 1–5: The speaker offers a farewell kiss and addresses someone who thinks the speaker’s days have been dreamlike. Rather than rejecting that view, the speaker accepts it. This personal parting introduces the poem’s larger concern with experiences that feel fleeting or difficult to hold as real.

Retci 6–11: The speaker considers whether hope vanished in a night or a day, in a vision or in none. These alternatives do not change the fact that hope is gone. A question about loss leads into a firm statement that everything people perceive or appear to be is a dream inside another dream.

Retci 12–18: The poem shifts to a noisy, wave-battered shore. The speaker holds a small amount of golden sand, but the grains slip through the fingers toward the sea. This physical struggle gives the earlier thoughts about loss a concrete image. The repeated mention of weeping makes the speaker’s distress immediate.

Retci 19–24: The speaker calls on God, asking for the power to grip the sand more tightly or save just one grain from the waves. These urgent appeals show how helpless the speaker feels. The closing question repeats the earlier idea about dreams but removes its certainty, leaving the nature of experience unsettled.

Besplatno 3 mjeseca

200.000+ klasika. Svaki format, besplatno za početak.

e-knjige i sažeci od 15 minuta te bilo koja knjiga tiskana po cijeni izrade, uključujući izdanje s krupnim tiskom.

Započni besplatnoObnavlja se svake godine · Otkaži kad god želiš

Tri pitanja za razmišljanje

How does the farewell at the beginning shape your understanding of the speaker’s later struggle with the sand?
What do the golden sand and the powerful waves suggest about what the speaker hopes to preserve?
How does changing the statement about dreams into a final question affect the poem’s meaning?

Besplatno 3 mjeseca

200.000+ klasika. Svaki format, besplatno za početak.

e-knjige i sažeci od 15 minuta te bilo koja knjiga tiskana po cijeni izrade, uključujući izdanje s krupnim tiskom.

Započni besplatnoObnavlja se svake godine · Otkaži kad god želiš

Sljedeća pjesmaThe Red WheelbarrowWilliams · Čitanje: 1 min

Iz djela Sabrana pjesnička djela

Pročitaj sažetak od 15 minuta i naruči tiskano izdanje, uključujući ono s velikim tiskom, po nabavnoj cijeni.

Isprobajte 3 mjeseca besplatno