Book summary
Trama e riassunto di Brevi studi su grandi argomenti
- 8 min di lettura
- 10 key ideas
- Audio a breve
A historian argues that history is a box of letters, and any theory can spell its word from the pieces.
3 months free · unlimited eBooks, audiobooks and summaries, and print and large print at cost
Nothing to pay today · Ti invieremo un’email prima dell’addebito · Annulla online in due clic
Brevi studi su grandi argomenti in breve
Riassunto: 8 min di lettura
- Tempo di lettura
- Circa 11 h 40 min9 h 15 min fast, 13 h 55 min slow
- Durata
- 166.600 parole
- Livello nella biblioteca
- Impegnativo long sentences, a rich vocabulary
- Prima pubblicazione
- 1867by James Anthony Froude
Reading time at 238 words a minute (fast 300, slow 200). Quanto tempo ci vuole per leggere i classici · Aggiornato
Gratis per 3 mesi
Ottieni il riassunto completo di Brevi studi su grandi argomenti, gratis
- 200.000+ classici in eBook, audiolibri e riassunti in 15 minuti, e libri cartacei e a caratteri grandi al costo di stampa
- Fino a 5 lettori in casa tua con un solo piano
Brevi studi su grandi argomenti in short
Froude's collection argues one thing from many angles. People cannot be reduced to laws, because they can choose to forget themselves, so history is a record to be read and not a science that forecasts. The best historians, like Homer and Shakespeare, let deeds speak and keep their own theories out of the way.
What Brevi studi su grandi argomenti is about
What if history is only a child's box of letters, from which you can spell any word you please? James Anthony Froude, a Victorian historian, asks exactly that in the first piece of this collection, a lecture given at the Royal Institution. He admits that a science of history sounds like talk about the colour of sound. Then he tests the idea against the facts.
Short Studies on Great Subjects gathers essays and lectures that Froude wrote in the 1850s and 1860s. They cover the Reformation, the Scottish Kirk, the monasteries, the Book of Job, Homer, Elizabeth's sea captains and a cunning medieval fox. Each asks how we should judge people and ideas from another age. Follow Froude's answer, and the Reformation, the saints and even the fables fall into place.
A chi è rivolto. Readers who enjoy Victorian argument, Reformation history, vivid portraits of Luther and Erasmus, and essays on how we judge the past will find plenty here. Lovers of Homer, sea adventure and fables will feel at home too.
The 10 key ideas
Key idea 1 · free to read
History cannot predict, so it is no science
Froude opens by facing the strongest case against him. Henry Buckle had argued that human conduct follows laws as fixed as the laws of the stars. If that is right, history reduces to cause and effect.
Froude asks what makes a subject a science. Its facts must fall into groups, and it must let us foresee what comes next. History cannot pass that test. Its events happen once, so no experiment is possible. Tacitus, looking at Rome, saw only a detestable superstition and could not have guessed what it would become.
Worse, a theory can always find its facts. A follower of Hegel or an admirer of the noble savage can each pick letters from the box and spell the word they came to spell. A pattern in the past is not a law until it can tell you what comes next.
- 2Inizia gratis per leggere
People who forget themselves cannot be calculated
Froude's deepest objection is moral.
- 3Inizia gratis per leggere
The best history lets deeds speak for themselves
If history cannot be a science, what is it for?
- 4Inizia gratis per leggere
A church keeps power only while it serves
In his lectures on Erasmus and Luther, given in Newcastle in 1867, Froude starts by clearing away myths.
- 5Inizia gratis per leggere
Erasmus shows learning needs a living conscience
Froude draws Erasmus as a brilliant, witty man born in Rotterdam in 1467.
- 6Inizia gratis per leggere
Luther stands on the courage to refuse lies
Froude's Luther is the son of a miner who entered the Augustinian monastery at Erfurt, tormented by guilt.
- 7Inizia gratis per leggere
Burning conviction carried Scotland through its crisis
Froude's Scottish lecture looks at the early sixteenth century, where the feudal bond was stronger than anywhere else in Europe.
- 8Inizia gratis per leggere
Honest belief welcomes open questions
In essays on belief, Froude argues that truth should be able to defend itself.
- 9Inizia gratis per leggere
Trust the record over the favourite legend
Froude trusts documents, and he prints records himself.
- 10Inizia gratis per leggere
We need examples of goodness to follow
In an essay on the lives of the saints, Froude argues that modern education lacks models.
Read all 10 key ideas now
3 months free, then 0,14 USD a day: unlimited eBooks, audiobooks and summaries, and print and large print at cost.
- Nothing to pay today
- Ti invieremo un’email prima dell’addebito
- Annulla online in due clic
The whole book is coming to your plan
The full text of Brevi studi su grandi argomenti opens soon. Keep this summary as a file today.
Paperback, hardcover and large print, printed for you at cost, are on their way. Email me when it is printed
Domande su Brevi studi su grandi argomenti
What is Short Studies on Great Subjects about?
It collects essays and lectures by James Anthony Froude on history, the Reformation, Luther and Erasmus, Scotland, belief, Spinoza, Homer, Elizabethan sailors and moral character, all asking how we should judge people and ideas from the past.
What does Froude mean by a child's box of letters?
He means that history can be arranged to spell any theory. A writer picks the facts that suit, ignores the rest, and so makes the past agree with his own opinion.
Does Froude think history is a science?
No. He says a science must let us foresee the future, and historical events never repeat. Because people can choose to act against self-interest, he holds that human conduct cannot be calculated like the stars.
What is the lecture on Erasmus and Luther about?
It sets two reformers side by side. Erasmus offers learning, wit and tolerance. Luther offers faith and honesty. Froude asks why the quiet scholar failed and the stubborn monk changed Europe.
Is this collection easy to follow?
Yes, because Froude argues through scenes, letters, portraits and fables. Each essay can be read alone, so you can start with the lectures on Erasmus and Luther or turn to the short animal tales.
Cita questa edizione
Froude, James Anthony. Short Studies on Great Subjects. Library of Alexandria, 2026, libraryofalexandria.com/products/short-studies-on-great-subjects.
Froude, J. A. (2026). Short studies on great subjects. Library of Alexandria. https://libraryofalexandria.com/products/short-studies-on-great-subjects (Original work published 1867)
Froude, James Anthony. Short Studies on Great Subjects. Library of Alexandria, 2026. https://libraryofalexandria.com/products/short-studies-on-great-subjects.
@book{froude2026short,
author = {Froude, James Anthony},
title = {Short Studies on Great Subjects},
publisher = {Library of Alexandria},
year = {2026},
url = {https://libraryofalexandria.com/products/short-studies-on-great-subjects},
note = {First published 1867}
}
Crime and Punishment
Wuthering Heights
Pride and Prejudice
The Iliad
Romeo and Juliet
The Picture of Dorian GrayGratis per 3 mesi
Ottieni il riassunto completo di Brevi studi su grandi argomenti, gratis
- 200.000+ classici in eBook, audiolibri e riassunti in 15 minuti, e libri cartacei e a caratteri grandi al costo di stampa
- Fino a 5 lettori in casa tua con un solo piano
