Riassunto
Riassunto di Al di là del principio di piacere
A chi è rivolto
For readers curious about why people repeat their mistakes, and for anyone who wants to meet Freud's thinking at a turning point.
Che cos’è questo libro
Beyond the Pleasure Principle is a short essay by Sigmund Freud, published in 1920 when he was in his sixties. For years he had held that the mind is steered by one aim, which is to gain pleasure and avoid pain. Then the First World War, his own patients, and a child's game gave him facts that did not fit. This essay is his attempt to deal with them, and it is where he first proposes a drive toward death.
The book is only about seven short chapters, but it changed psychoanalysis. It introduces the idea of repetition compulsion, the urge to act out painful experiences again and again. It also sets out a speculative theory of two great forces in life. Freud is unusually frank here. He calls his ideas speculation and admits he is not sure he believes them. You will hear how he builds his case step by step, and what he asks of you at each step. Let us begin with the principle he starts from, and the first cracks in it.
In questo riassunto
- 1The mind seeks pleasure, but not alwaysFree
- 2Trauma makes the mind relive its pain
- 3A child's game shows repetition at work
- 4Patients and fates repeat what hurts them
- 5Instincts pull backward toward an earlier state
- 6Eros and death, and what comes after
Punto chiave 1 di 6
The mind seeks pleasure, but not always
Freud opens with the pleasure principle. This is the view that mental life aims to lower tension, which we feel as unpleasure, and to reach a state of calm and satisfaction. He borrows from the physicist and philosopher Gustav Fechner the idea that the mind tends toward stability. Freud links this to what he calls the constancy principle, the effort to keep the level of excitation as low as possible.
But the pleasure principle cannot rule alone, and Freud says so. If it did, we would chase every wish at once and often come to harm. So the mind learns to bend to the outer world. This second rule he names the reality principle. It delays or gives up some satisfactions because the world forbids them, and it accepts a little pain for a safer gain later.
Even so, Freud notes that much unpleasure does not come from this clash with reality. It comes from conflicts inside the mind itself. A wish that is allowed in one part of the mind may bring pain to another part, because it has been repressed. The person feels distress where satisfaction would be expected.
This opening matters because it sets the problem. Freud does not throw out the pleasure principle. He asks whether it is the whole story, and he points to some mental events that seem to lie beyond it. The rest of the essay is an attempt to look at those events honestly.
That’s 1 of 6 key points.
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
- Nothing to pay today · Renews every year
- We email you before you pay
- Cancel online in two clicks
About this edition
Every format is free to start, and print and large print are at cost.
- LengthAbout 24,000 words
- Reading timeAbout 1 h 35 min
- Listening time2 h 40 min
- FormatseBook, large-print eBook, audiobook, 15-minute summary
- LanguagesEnglish and 10 other languages
Questions about Al di là del principio di piacere
What is Beyond the Pleasure Principle about?
It asks why people repeat painful experiences if the mind seeks pleasure. Freud looks at war trauma, a child's game and patients in analysis, and proposes a drive toward death alongside the life drive, Eros.
What is the death drive?
It is Freud's idea that living things have a basic urge to return to an earlier, inorganic state, which means a pull toward rest and death. He offers it as speculation, and later analysts have disagreed about it.
What is repetition compulsion?
It is the urge to repeat painful or disturbing experiences, in dreams, in behaviour or in relationships. Freud saw it in trauma survivors and in patients who acted out old conflicts with their analyst.
What is the fort-da game in Freud's essay?
It is a game Freud saw his small grandson play. The boy threw a reel away and pulled it back, saying fort for gone and da for there, to cope with his mother's absences.
Is Beyond the Pleasure Principle hard to read?
It mixes psychology, biology and philosophy. The early chapters with the child's game and the war dreams are easy to follow.