The Brothers Karamazov, Part 4, Chapter 9 summary
Part 4, Chapter 9 of 96 · 32 min to read the chapter
In Chapter 9, Ivan, close to brain fever, argues with a devilish visitor whom he identifies as a projection of his own worst thoughts. Their dispute exposes his struggle over belief and moral responsibility, before knocking breaks the nightmare and Alyosha announces that Smerdyakov has killed himself.
What happens
- The narrator describes Ivan’s worsening illness, his admitted hallucinations, and his refusal to follow a doctor’s urgent advice.
- A shabby gentleman appears, and Ivan insists that the visitor embodies his own degrading thoughts rather than an independent being.
- The visitor mixes comic stories with arguments about suffering, faith, and his supposed duty to oppose goodness.
- Ivan recognizes a story from his youth, but the visitor uses that recognition to deepen his uncertainty about reality.
- The visitor repeats ideas about rejecting God and abandoning moral limits, until Ivan throws a glass at him.
- Knocking interrupts the nightmare; the visitor disappears, the glass remains on the table, and Alyosha reports Smerdyakov’s suicide.
Free for 3 months
Get the full summary of The Brothers Karamazov, free
- 200,000+ classics as eBooks, audiobooks and 15-minute summaries, and print and large print at cost
- Up to 5 readers in your home on one plan
Commencez 90 jours gratuitsNothing to pay today. 0,14 USD a day in the first year, then 0,27 USD a day.
In this chapter
What to notice
Ivan treats the argument as a conflict within himself. His hostility toward the visitor also expresses disgust with thoughts he recognizes as his own.
Quick check
What does Ivan notice about the glass when the nightmare breaks?
Free for 3 months
Get the full summary of The Brothers Karamazov, free
- 200,000+ classics as eBooks, audiobooks and 15-minute summaries, and print and large print at cost
- Up to 5 readers in your home on one plan
Commencez 90 jours gratuitsNothing to pay today. 0,14 USD a day in the first year, then 0,27 USD a day.
200,000+ classics to read, hear and hold
15-minute summaries today, eBooks and audiobooks as each book opens, and printed books, large print included, at cost.
Try 3 months free
