Résumé
Résumé de Les Aventures du Dr Thorndyke (L’Os chantant)
Go deeper: the whole of Les Aventures du Dr Thorndyke (L’Os chantant)
About 4 h 40 min to read.À qui s’adresse-t-il ?
Readers who love clever puzzles, scientific clues and London life will enjoy these tales. They offer the quiet satisfaction of watching a careful mind turn small facts into proof.
De quoi parle ce livre ?
Why would an author show you the crime first and then ask you to watch a detective work it out? R. Austin Freeman does exactly that in The Adventures of Dr. Thorndyke, also called The Singing Bone. In five tales, the medico-legal expert Dr. Thorndyke and his friend Dr. Jervis read dust, glass, pipes and fingerprints as if they were pages of a book. In the first four tales, you see the crime before the investigation begins. The pleasure lies in how the proof is found. The preface explains the plan, so begin there.
Dans ce résumé
- 1Freeman turns the detective story inside outFree
- 2A hospitable burglar meets an unlucky stranger
- 3Thorndyke reads a railway death from small clues
- 4A quiet man plans a careful disappearance
- 5Thorndyke doubts what the bloodhounds seem to prove
- 6A lighthouse keeper with a secret expects a companion
- 7The singing bone and the story told by a pipe
- 8A dance, a mistaken coat and a trail of dust
- 9A frightened visitor faces fingerprint evidence
Point clé 1 sur 9
Freeman turns the detective story inside out
In his preface, Freeman says the usual question, who did it, is the wrong one. He believes readers care more about how the discovery is made. So in four of these five tales the reader sees the crime first and knows every fact before the detective does.
He tests the idea in The Case of Oscar Brodski. The reader knows everything, the detective knows nothing, and the interest rests on the surprising meaning of small things. The story wins approval and brings requests for more, so he writes three further stories in the same mould.
The fifth tale, The Old Lag, is told in the usual way, so you can compare the two methods. As you read, notice how often a trivial detail you saw at the start returns as the key to the whole case.
That’s 1 of 9 key points.
The rest of the summary, written and spoken, and the whole book: free to start.
- Nothing to pay today · Renews every year
- We email you before you pay
- Cancel online in two clicks
Go deeper: the whole of Les Aventures du Dr Thorndyke (L’Os chantant)
About 4 h 40 min to read.Who’s who
- Dr. John Thorndyke
- A physician and barrister, Thorndyke examines scientific evidence with help from his colleague Jervis and laboratory assistant Polton.
- Dr. Christopher Jervis
- Jervis is Thorndyke's honest, capable friend and junior colleague, following cases beside him and asking questions about the evidence.
- Nathaniel Polton
- Polton is Thorndyke's devoted laboratory assistant, skilled at making instruments and photographs for his master's investigations.
- The criminals
- These careful, confident schemers believe they have hidden every trace, setting their ingenuity against Thorndyke's scientific scrutiny.
About this edition
Every format is free to start, and print and large print are at cost.
- LengthAbout 71,000 words
- Reading timeAbout 4 h 40 min
- FormatseBook, large-print eBook, audiobook, 15-minute summary
- LanguagesEnglish and 11 other languages
Questions about Les Aventures du Dr Thorndyke (L’Os chantant)
What is The Singing Bone about?
It is a collection of five Dr. Thorndyke mysteries by R. Austin Freeman. In four of them the reader sees the crime first, then watches Thorndyke find the truth from small physical clues.
Why is it called The Singing Bone?
The title belongs to the lighthouse story. It recalls a German folk tale in which a musical instrument made from a bone tells of a crime. The image suits a detective who studies what ordinary objects can tell him.
Do I need to read the Thorndyke books in order?
No. Each tale stands on its own, with Jervis explaining who Thorndyke and Polton are. The preface gives a helpful key to the inverted structure.
What is an inverted detective story?
It shows the crime and the criminal first. The suspense comes from watching how the detective works out what the reader already knows. Freeman called it the process rather than the result.
Is it worth reading today?
Yes, for readers who like fair-play puzzles. The tales are short, the clues are clear, and the science of dust, glass, pipes and fingerprints is explained plainly.